Pro Asset Protection

Attorney Ike Devji

  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Facts and FAQ’s
  • Asset Protection Attorney Ike Devji – Bio
  • Home
  • Off the Record
  • Reputation and Recognition

Employee Lawsuit Exposure – Retaliation Claims

February 4, 2011 by Ike Devji, Asset Protection Attorney Leave a Comment

 

Employment Law Expert Paul Edwards

RETALIATION CLAIMS – JUST HOW CAREFUL SHOULD YOU BE?  

  New Form of Retaliation Lawsuit Green Lighted by Supreme Court! 

  • Supreme court rules that third party employee are entitled to sue employers for retaliation.
  • Retaliation tops the EEOC claims list for the first time in 2011- It’s where the contingency fee dollars get collected.
  • Most agree the Green Light will cause more litigation against employers.
  • Most employers don’t understand they may win on the original complaint(sexual harassment, wages, pregnancy)  and still lose a retaliation claim.
  • Employers with two or more family members who work for them, may want to adopt anti-nepotism policies going forward.
  • Employees not related to one another just gained access to file lawsuits with retaliation claims.
  • Highlights the need to have a bullet proof employee handbook with updated policies and support available when taking an adverse action against an employee.
  • Employers that lean on their At Will status with no written record of the issues leading up to terminations and other adverse actions,  are way more vulnerable now.

By now, every employer in the country should have learned that you can’t “retaliate” against an employee because they have made a claim for employment discrimination.  That includes all the standard flavors such as race, religion, gender, sexual harassment, age, disability, national origin and perhaps even sexual orientation.

For those of you that have a pair or more of family members working for you this, January 2011, case means that you need to consider even more of the “factors” before terminating an employee. In this incredibly damaging ruling for  employers, the third party was not even family yet.  

But this employer never expected he would have to shell out a pile of cash when he terminated the fiancée of a woman who had filed a claim of sex discrimination.  To be sure, the employer took no action against the woman (Ms. Regalado)…just let her claim wind its way through the legal system.  I guess he thought that by firing her fiancée he would put pressure on her to relent in the pursuit of her claim. Also, my guess is he had probably been told by his lawyer that Title VII does not permit third party retaliation claims. Well, turns out he and his lawyer were dead wrong!  

The fired fiancée found a creative attorney (believe me, there will always be one lurking out there) who filed a retaliation claim on his behalf against the former employer who thought his actions were protected.  The defendant in the case, Thompson v. North American Stainless, decided by the Supreme Court on January 24, 2011, raised two seemingly strong defenses to the suit.  First, that Thompson had no cause of action since he was not an “aggrieved person” under the statute and therefore did not have standing to sue.  The argument being that only Ms. Regalado, the person who filed the claim of discrimination (the protected activity), could be an “aggrieved person” under the statute.  Secondly, North American argued that Thompson’s firing was not “unlawful” since he had done nothing overtly to support Ms. Regalado’s claim and termination of a  person who wasn’t a party to the action was not prohibited by the express language of the statute.  

The Court made short shrift of the second argument, ruling that the test was whether the employer’s action well might have dissuaded a reasonable worker from engaging in protected activity (i.e. prosecuting her claim of discrimination).  Seriously, can there be any doubt Ms. Regalado would feel pressured by Thompson’s  termination.  They were engaged to be married.  

The first defense gave the court little pause either.  The statute states simply that a “cause of action may be brought by the person claiming to be aggrieved.”  The Court rejected North American’s position that “person aggrieved” refers only to the employee who engaged in the protected activity, saying that was “artificially narrow.”  However, the Court was unwilling to accept Thompson’s all inclusive argument that standing should be controlled by the exceptionally broad standards of Article III of the Constitution.  

Instead, the Court took a balancing position, writing “[T]hompson is not an accidental victim of the retaliation – collateral damage, so to speak, of the employer’s unlawful act. To the contrary, injuring him was the employer’s intended means of harming Regalado (the employee). Hurting him was the unlawful act by which the employer punished her. In those circumstances, we think Thompson well within the zone of interests sought to be protected by Title VII. He is a person aggrieved with standing to sue”  

So what is the lesson to be learned from Thompson?  Simply put, if you ever are subjected to a claim of discrimination, regardless of whether you think it is valid,  you neither touch the so called “aggrieved” employee nor any family member, fiancée, close friend or other person who may be supporting the employee in his/her claim of discrimination.

Guest Author Paul Edwards is the Co-Founder and CEO of The Center for Employment Dispute Resolution, LLC (CEDR).  CEDR is an independent LLC dedicated to providing products and information that support employers nationwide. You can find out more information at www.cedrsolutions.com including a full listing of their employment specialist partners, products and services. Paul’s flagship product is a customized for your office and state employee handbook with on-going support.  

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

See Ike’s Work In Action

· Ike Devji on Acrimoney.com
· Ike Devji on CFO ADVISORS
· Ike Devji on Infosec Island
· Ike Devji on Risk and Threat Management

Money Matters Interview

Recent Posts

  • The Business Roundtable Podcast: Asset Protection
  • The Risks of Doing Business With Family Members
  • Campaign Contributions: What Business Owners Need to Know
  • Recession Asset Protection – Is My Bank Safe?
  • Asset Protection for Pain Management Doctors and Anesthesiologists

Categories

  • 2012 Economy (3)
  • 2013 Economy (3)
  • 2020 Recession (1)
  • 529 and College Savings Plans (1)
  • abusive tax schemes (13)
  • APT (3)
  • Arizona (19)
  • arizona anti-deficiency statutes (5)
  • Arizona Asset Protection (33)
  • arizona bankruptcy (4)
  • arizona economy (13)
  • Arizona Estate Planning (11)
  • arizona forclosure (8)
  • arizona real esate (12)
  • Asset Protection (174)
  • Asset Protection Education (16)
  • Asset Protection for Doctors (36)
  • Asset Protection for Your Home (7)
  • Asset Protection Fraud and Failures (22)
  • asset protection law (25)
  • asset protection strategies (42)
  • asset protection trusts (33)
  • Baby Boomers (5)
  • Banking and Bank Solvency (5)
  • Bankruptcy (8)
  • Best Money Market rates (1)
  • brokers (1)
  • Business Asset Protection (3)
  • business law (3)
  • business legal planning (72)
  • business owner and entrepreneur (15)
  • Business Owners (28)
  • business survival (48)
  • business valuation (6)
  • buy sell agreement (5)
  • captive insurance company (8)
  • Cars and Automobile Liability (4)
  • Cash Alernatives (2)
  • CEO (27)
  • children (8)
  • chiropractors (35)
  • CIO (1)
  • closely held business (30)
  • commercial real estate (8)
  • Coronavirus (2)
  • cpa (20)
  • creditor negotiation (4)
  • creditor protected cash alternatives (5)
  • Crisis Management Planning (7)
  • CTO (1)
  • DAPT (3)
  • debt (4)
  • deficiency judgment (2)
  • defined benefit plans (2)
  • dentists (57)
  • Director and Officer Liability (10)
  • disability insurance (2)
  • Divorce (5)
  • doctor sued (44)
  • Doctors (54)
  • Domestic Asset Protection Trusts (2)
  • Due Dilligence (11)
  • economy (9)
  • employee social media usage (3)
  • Employment law (25)
  • Entrepreneurs (5)
  • equity (1)
  • ESTATE MANAGEMENT (2)
  • estate planning (29)
  • estate tax (12)
  • estate taxes (3)
  • Expatriation (1)
  • face book (3)
  • family business (19)
  • Family Legal Planning (7)
  • family liability (11)
  • family limited partnership (4)
  • Family Office (8)
  • FAMILY OFFICE ISSUES (6)
  • FDIC Insurance Limits (2)
  • finacial advisors (7)
  • Finance (12)
  • financial advisors (23)
  • FINANCIAL ISSUES FOR DOCTORS (47)
  • financial literacy (56)
  • financing (6)
  • firearms (5)
  • forclosure (2)
  • foreclosure (3)
  • foreign bank accounts (7)
  • fraud (18)
  • fraudulent conveyance (3)
  • funding (3)
  • Geri Custer (1)
  • gifting (1)
  • Gifting – Wealth Transfer (4)
  • Greg George (5)
  • GTI ADVISORS (5)
  • Gun trusts (1)
  • guns (7)
  • HEALTH CARE LAW (6)
  • high net worth (17)
  • HIPPA violations (1)
  • homeowner's liability (13)
  • HR (3)
  • IAPT (2)
  • id theft (4)
  • Ike Devji (100)
  • Ike Devji – Asset Protection Expert (5)
  • ILIT (2)
  • information security (5)
  • intangible assets (3)
  • intellectual property (1)
  • investing (12)
  • investment exposure (14)
  • IRA creditor protection (1)
  • IRA Trusts (1)
  • Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust (3)
  • IRS (7)
  • Jeff Christenson (4)
  • Jumbo CD Rates (1)
  • kids (6)
  • lawsuit awards (23)
  • lawyers (8)
  • Leadership & Management (12)
  • leading wealth and legal advisors (2)
  • legal documents and records (3)
  • Legal Strategies (19)
  • liability (46)
  • liability insurance (35)
  • Life Insurance (13)
  • life Insurance conversions (1)
  • LIFE INSURANCE CREDITOR PROTECTION (2)
  • Life Insurnace Conversions (2)
  • Limited Liability Companies (2)
  • Limited Partnerships and FLPs (1)
  • linkedIn (1)
  • LLC Asset Protection (3)
  • LLC Myths (2)
  • Loan default (4)
  • Lotzer Law Group (1)
  • malpractice (14)
  • malpractice insurance (2)
  • marketing and reputataion management (2)
  • Marriage and Family (2)
  • Medical Marijuana (1)
  • Medical Practice Management (23)
  • medical practice mangement (31)
  • Medical Practice Risk Management (14)
  • mexican real estate (1)
  • Mortgage (1)
  • Municipal Bonds (2)
  • Nevada (1)
  • offshore (16)
  • offshore banking (9)
  • offshore trusts (13)
  • parenting (7)
  • partnerships (2)
  • personal finance (2)
  • personal injury (8)
  • personal security (9)
  • physicians (41)
  • physicians personal finance (3)
  • privacy and identity (2)
  • professional athletes (27)
  • professional entertainers (17)
  • property insurance (7)
  • rachel weiss (5)
  • Raisng Capital and Funding Your Business (1)
  • real estate investing (14)
  • recession (12)
  • recession lawsuits (13)
  • recession survival (32)
  • Reputation and Recognition (1)
  • reputation management (1)
  • Retirement Plan Creditor Protection (2)
  • retirement plan funding (2)
  • Richard Arnold (1)
  • risk management (11)
  • scams (13)
  • Scottsdale (1)
  • Sean Shepherd (3)
  • SEC (1)
  • secret bank accounts (6)
  • SECURITY (5)
  • shelf corporations (1)
  • small business (3)
  • social media (5)
  • start-ups (7)
  • startup (5)
  • Strategic Default (4)
  • Succession and Transition Planning (5)
  • Surgeons and Surgical Centers (5)
  • tax deductions (19)
  • tax fraud (7)
  • taxation (17)
  • taxes (23)
  • THE VAULT (2)
  • Trisha Lotzer (1)
  • trusts (4)
  • twitter (1)
  • Uncategorized (52)
  • up front fees (1)
  • Urgent Care Centers (1)
  • vacant real estate liability (4)
  • venture capital (6)
  • wealth transfer (5)
  • Wealth Transfer Strategies (13)
  • women & money (8)
  • Workplace Violence (2)
  • worth magazine (4)

Copyright © 2021 · Dynamik-Gen on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in